If I had an opportunity to change The Garden of Forking Paths, the only change I would do is main
character. Although having Yu Tsun did contribute to the effectiveness of the
story, I believe that the time period was not appropriate to use Yu for the
story. The only reason I say this is because Asians were not involved in the
World War One for the European side. Now if the story was based off of World
War Two, then it would make more sense that Yu is working for the Germans to destroy
the Allies. Even in this case, it would still make no sense because it is said
that Dr. Albert was listening to Chinese music. The only reason this is
important is because Dr. Albert was currently studying Yu’s ancestor, Ts’ui
Pen. We can conclude that Yu must be Chinese and historically, the Chinese
helping the Germans in World War Two would still not make sense because the
Chinese were being attacked by the Japanese, an ally of Germany. It would make
more sense to change the main character to a different race only for the
purpose of making this short fictional story more realistically possible. To
keep the overall structure of the story, Yu should be considered Japanese in
order to comply with the historical features of the story.
No comments:
Post a Comment